Carnegie Hill vs Astoria: Safety Comparison

Side-by-side safety comparison for two of NYC’s most popular neighborhoods. Which is safer for renters in 2026?

Updated June 28, 2026

	Carnegie Hill Manhattan	Astoria Queens
Safety Grade	B	B
30-Day Incidents	184	124
Violent Crime	11	5
Robbery	10	5
Drug Activity	0	0

Verdict

Astoria is currently safer with 124 incidents vs 184 in Carnegie Hill. Safety grades: Carnegie Hill (B) vs Astoria (B).

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carnegie Hill or Astoria safer?

Astoria currently has fewer incidents (124 vs 184 in the last 30 days) and a B safety grade.

Which has more violent crime?

Carnegie Hill: 11 violent incidents. Astoria: 5. These counts reflect the last 30 days.

Compare Other Neighborhoods

• Carnegie Hill vs Park Slope
• Carnegie Hill vs Williamsburg
• Carnegie Hill vs Crown Heights
• Carnegie Hill vs Bushwick
• Carnegie Hill vs Bed-Stuy
• Carnegie Hill vs Harlem
• Carnegie Hill vs Upper West Side
• Carnegie Hill vs Hell's Kitchen